Critique of Infinity Comics

ss+(2015-10-29+at+09.10.43)

Over this session I have been following Jake’s digital artifact which was reworking Infinity Comics. Jake’s digital artifact is really just a continuation and expansion of his already developed online presence. He has been blogging at detective-comics.tumblr.com for around 5 years (and more recently also at his marvel blog ultimate-marvel.tumblr.com). This project was really just a natural progression of his aforementioned online presence.

Aims

Jake’s aim was to re-work a group blog he founded  two years ago with fellow well-known tumblr bloggers called Infinity Comics. Jake’s original vision for Infinity was to gather bloggers that each had a unique blogging style and create a sort of ‘haven of comic information’. An all-inclusive resource that would allow tumblr users to find information relevant to their interests without having to leave the medium. But when one of the core members had to leave due to time constraints the blog sort of stagnated with the rest of the members trying to post content whenever they could but it was nothing like what Jake had originally envisioned. So for this project Jake has tried to revitalise this blog and push it towards his original vision.

Concepts and Methodology

The methods Jake has used to redesign his blog were as far as I could tell non academic but in this scenario it was academia really necessary. Being a prominent member in the comic book community on tumblr gave him an insight into his subject matter that no article really could. The decisions relating to design and content choices were informed by demand from his already established fan base.

The Redesigned Index Page

Jake has created a few additional pages that serve as resources for different material. First off the index page. The redesigned index page makes it easy for users to find posts that are relevant and interesting to them. This is a major thing for me because with a lot of tumblr blogs to find what you want you have to sift through enormous amounts of content which can be very tedious. Unless the posts are tagged correctly to make them searchable but a lot of users don’t seem to utilize this.

Next he has created a Creators on tumblr page that allows users to find people within the comic industry that use tumblr. There is a bio on each creator, a list of the notable works and links to all of their other social media channels. This is another valuable resource for any tumblr user new or old. I think a lot of users associate tumblr blogs with more fan created content and probably don’t realise that these people who work within the industry also use the medium.

The final additional page that Jake created was the comic book movie list. This list features 184 comic book based movies all ranked through an average of the IMDB and Rotten Tomatoes score. Similar to the Creators on tumblr this is another invaluable resource to both comic book aficionados and newbies. For the experienced user you may find a movie you hadn’t seen and for the uninformed it offers a resource that may help them dive into the world of comic book movies.

The Movie List

Trajectory

As I stated earlier Jake is an already established presence so he is a different spot to the majority of the other projects. The newly reinvented infinity comics blog will continue to operate with a few new contributors who will each contribute their own unique content. Hopefully this is something that Jake is able to leverage in the future as it has progressed well beyond just a ‘blog about batman’. I would love to see him use the resource that is the other members of the blog and try to branch beyond tumblr. Possibly creating YouTube content or a podcast series relating to comic books, leveraging the audience of each members respective followers.

Feedback

Visually all of the pages are very well designed. The content pops of the page and the interface is slick and easy to use. The only downside to the design is the menu that leads to some of the best content on the blog ‘JR’s comic collection’, Nini’s ‘where to start guides’ and the movie list has some really small font. It almost feels as if they are hidden away. The size of the font on this menu could also hinder accessibility for vision impaired users.

dazxSpace that could be used for bio/links

The movie list could benefit from a small bio on each movie as well as stating which comic book each movie is based on. A small bio such as the IMDB bio would aid newer users who are unfamiliar with these movies. Also there could be a link to each movies respective IMDB or Wiki page. Adding which comic each movie is based on might seem unnecessary as most of the time the source material is in the name of the movie but in some cases it’s not really obvious e.g Edge Of Tomorrow is based on All You Need Is Kill. Runtime is a weird thing to list first. I think the order should go something like Based on > Directed by > Starring (Better than featuring) > Runtime > Infinity Rating. Im guessing that the majority of things have not been done due to time constraints and while they aren’t essential they could raise the already great content to another level.

Overall Jake has really aced the redesign and revitalization of Infinity Comics. It was really hard to find things to critique as he did such a good job. I look forward to seeing where Infinity Comics goes in the future.

Advertisements

Stardom 5 Star GP: Final Thoughts

12027120_869974553098809_4818778363694838594_oSource: Ichiban Drunk

For my second round of auto-ethnographic researching I decided to look at Japanese wrestling. The show in particular I chose to focus on was the first night of Stardom’s 5 Star GP tournament. Just finding the show was an experience in itself. After hours of searching and joining closed Facebook groups I finally found links to watch the show in its entirety. It was actually the first time I’ve watched a Japanese Joshi show from start to finish. I’ve seen a few acclaimed Joshi matches on YouTube but never a full show. I have always been intrigued by Joshi but never really knew how to follow it.

It’s quite hard to get access to the shows and matches internationally. Thankfully fans share a lot of content and that’s how I was able to access this show. It’s sort of sad that there is not option for international fans to support these shows. New Japan Pro Wrestling (the biggest wrestling promotion in Japan currently) has recently opened a streaming platform that’s available internationally. It features a large amount of their back catalogue and live shows for a small subscription. So hopefully its successful and other Japanese companies follow suit.

I went with a sort of review/reaction format because it just felt natural when talking about wrestling. I think this is because I get most of the Japanese wrestling related content through reviews. As I stated in my review I liked the show, especially the Io/Mayu match up. It was exemplary of what I believe modern Joshi (Japanese women’s wrestling) should be.

Stardom is one of the more ‘glamour’ focused promotions currently running in Japan. They even have a TV show Stardom Cafe that is “a monthly show that features the Stardom roster hanging out at restaurants and features an assortment of various clips from matches, modeling, and traveling.”(Source)

But Stardom seems like its in a sort of middle ground. It has the ‘glamour’ stuff but still puts on great matches. I feel as if this balance allows it to not feel like they are blatantly using sex to sell tickets.

Live Reaction/Review: Stardom 5 Star GP Night One – Part 2

11878955_901401863267790_7688035897506753220_o-1
Chelsea and Kairi Hojo trade dropkicks (Source: Stardom Joshi Puroresu)

Continuing my review of the first night of the Stardom 5 Star GP. If you missed the first part you can find it here. As I noted at the end of that review I enjoyed what I saw but nothing blew me away. So lets see what the final 3 matches have in store.

Starfire Vs. KAORU

KAORU is another veteran of the Japanese women’s scene. She’s been around for 20-25 years. Starfire is a younger wrestler from Mexico that wears a Lucha mask which is always cool to see. The match started out with a lot of shady moves from KAORU. She did everything from choking Starfire with the robe she wore to the ring to pulling her hair. This led to Starfire and her friends doing a few shady things of their own. Kris Wolf who wrestled earlier was at ringside supporting Starfire and jumped into the ring to break up a few pinfalls. I’m guessing this is to create something between KAORU and Wolf because they are probably facing each other later on in the tournament. They then started brawling outside the ring and into the crowd. I was grateful for this as it gave me my first look into the Stardom demographic which from what I could see was mostly males from 20-40 (Spotted a few female fans, through they looked like girlfriends that had been dragged along). After they brawled outside we got our ‘finishing stretch’. Starfire hit a very cool double underhook into face buster but KAORU mostly dominated this and picked up the victory with a twisting moonsault. This match was fun. I’m a sucker for brawling through the crowd and shady hijinks. While the actually wrestling was sloppy at times this was a fun showcase for the legend KAORU.

stardom8.23-5
Starfire being thrown into the crowd by KAORU (Source: puroresucentral.com)

Io Shirai vs. Mayu Iwatani

Ok this should be something special, I’ve heard a lot of buzz around this match on various forums. These 2 are pretty much the top 2 wrestlers in Stardom. They are currently a tag team and very close friends. That combination always seems to produce good matches. Commentary mentions Io is the ace or something along those lines which is interesting, Ace is predominantly something used by fans to describe the ‘top guy’ in a certain promotion to my knowledge. Mayu got a ton of streamers and they were the same colours as her gear. Dedication by the fans there. Also just as a note for future reference there has been a female commentator this entire show which is something different. Some very vocal female fans cheering for Io early on, maybe my demographic assumptions were a little off.

stardom8.23-7
Mayu hits Io with a big splash from the top (Source: puroresucentral.com)

Picture perfect grappling and counters from both in the early going. Very back and forth. Io hit a bodyslam on the ring apron ouch. Since the body slam Io has taken over. Io hit a very stiff looking dropkick to a seated Mayu. Io gets a bit cocky showboating before a springboard dive and Mayu takes control. Hits her own dropkick to a seated Io knocking her out of the ring, a big dive from the top to Io on the floor outside the ring then Mayu dumps Io on her head with a brutal dragon suplex on the floor. It got crazy from this point on. Big strike exchanges, beautiful suplexes and in the end Mayu hit a reverse hurricanrana from the top that looked insane, Io kicked out but the time limit expired. Announcers sound startled and so am I, completely forgot there was a time limit as I was so engaged in the match. I could watch these two wrestle all night so the time limit draw was a bit of a bummer but it makes sense for a tournament match. Gives them an angle they could go back to in the future and makes you wonder if Mayu was really just about to beat the ace of Stardom Io Shirai. If someone wanted an introduction into modern women’s wrestling in Japan I would show them this. It was fantastic.

stardom8.23-8
Mayu’s reverse hurricanrana (Source: puroresucentral.com)

Chelsea vs. Kairi Hojo

Another tag team partner matchup as both of these to form a tag team called Candy Crush. Chelsea is an American that doesn’t speak Japanese if the pre match video is to believed and I don’t think Kairi speaks much English. They do seem very friendly though. I think Chelsea is throwing candy to the crowd. Kairi is coming out to a variation of the Pirates of the Caribbean music and came out with a pirate hat and a ship wheel it was pretty great. From what I can pick up from the commentary team Kairi is the former stardom champion. After some grappling at the start and the classic test of strength it has been mostly Kairi on offence so far. Chelsea has now taken over and is working heavily on the arm of Kairi. The arm work makes a lot of sense in this scenario because a lot of Kairi’s offence seems to revolve around elbows. Kairi was in control until Chelsea caught her with arm capture roll up for the victory. The young American upsets her partner and the former champion. This match was good but it couldn’t reach the levels of the previous match. It was worked at a much slower pace and never really ‘got going’. This is the first day of the tournament and having to go after that previous match is very tough so I’ll give them a pass.

stardom8.23-9
Kairi hits Chelsea with a short arm spear (Source: puroresucentral.com)

Overall this was quite a good show for being just the first day of a tournament. It was a great introduction to Stardom. The Io/Mayu match is the obvious stand out but nothing was bad at all. Everything was good to great. I will definitely be keeping my eye out for Stardom shows in the future.

Live Reaction/Review: Stardom 5 Star GP Night One – Part 1

8089e50294910c6cb163e5cb54ad137b

This is my first experience with Stardom but I am fairly familiar with Japanese Wrestling in general. Stardom is an all female wrestling promotion based in Japan. The 5 Star GP is an annual tournament that they run. It features a round robin system with 2 blocks (Blue/Red) with the block winners facing each other to crown the tournament champion.

Match 1: Azumi Vs. Momo Watanabe

I’ll be honest no idea who is who in this one. Both wrestlers are quite short and the commentators keep saying ‘kid fight’ so I think that’s why these two are paired together. Also I’m pretty sure this is a non tournament match. It seemed like a bit of a throwaway match to just warm up the crowd. Well they are both actually kids that’s why the announcers were saying ‘kid fight’ Azumi is 12 years old and Momo is 15. Ok the match is already over, it was really short with Momo (I think) winning. The work was fine but it was too short to be anything special was more a showcase for the youngsters (Something that is very common for the opening match in Japan).

Momo Watanabe hits a Somato (Source: puroresucentral.com)
Momo Watanabe hits a Somato (Source: puroresucentral.com)

Match 2: Kris Wolf Vs. La Rosa Negra

This is the first tournament match. Kris Wolf’s entrance involved her playing rock,paper, scissors with a fan it was amazing. The fans are howling at Kris Wolf so that must be her thing. So Kris Wolf is playing the small, upbeat bundle of energy roll and La Rosa is in the serious business ‘I ain’t got times for your games’ role. It was about 5 minutes longer that the previous match but they didn’t really use that time to build a strong story or anything. They just had a decent match but that was it really. The finish was sort of anticlimactic with La Rosa winning with a frog splash.

Frog Splash From La Rosa Negra ( Source: puroresucentral.com)
Frog Splash From La Rosa Negra (Source: puroresucentral.com)

Match 3: Haruka Kato vs. Queen Maya

Another tournament match that finds the giant European Queen Maya against the poor little Kato. Something to take note of both Kato and Wolf got streamers thrown at them when they were introduced but both of the foreigners didn’t? Anyway this was quite short. Really just a showcase for Queen Maya who seems a bit limited wrestling wise but makes up for it because of her size. Kato got a few bits of offence in but eventually was taken out with a brutal lariat into a chokeslam.

Match 4: Hudson Envy vs Kaori Yoneyama

Hudson Envy is obviously the villain, I mean just say that name aloud it sounds so evil. I think I’ve cracked the streamer debacle. They are thrown for the fan favourites or good guys. Yoneyama got them but Envy didn’t. Yoneyama was at the size disadvantage here but she didn’t let that stop her as she wrestled a very fast paced and aggressive style. I have a feeling she’s a veteran as she seems older than Envy. Doesn’t move like she’s older though she’s flying around the ring. Anyway the match ended with Envy hitting a nice air raid crash. This was the best match so far, it was a little short but it was face paced with little to no down time.

I’ll continue with the second half of the show next week. I’m enjoying it so far but nothing has really blown me away.

And That’s The End Of That Chapter

Godzilla in a scene from the film 'Godzilla VS. The Smog Monster', 1971. Toho/Getty Images
Godzilla in a scene from the film ‘Godzilla VS. The Smog Monster’, 1971. Toho/Getty Images

Summary time. In my first post I focused on just analysing Godzilla because I had no idea what I was doing. I just pressed record and talked for a few minutes about the movie. Luckily I came up with a point about language becoming white noise that made some sense so I thought I’d look into that.

For my second post I chose to focus on Language in Asian media using my Godzilla ‘white noise’ experience as a jumping off point. My original plan was to use research I found on language as a starting point and then go into examples of different kinds language in Asian media. But when I was recording I went off on a massive tangent about subtitles and their importance. And when I listened back to this I thought it was better than my initial idea so I just went with it.

4wNS0hB

The importance of subtitles is something I have always thought about. The idea that something is instantly defined as foreign because of their presence. They cause media to be immediately judged as either not worth the effort because “I watch movies so I don’t have to read” or as pretentious foreign drivel.

“Every film is a foreign film, foreign to some audience somewhere.” – Atom Egoyan and Ian Balfour, Subtitles

Asian media seems to be thought of as the most ‘foreign’ and ‘exotic’ but it really shouldn’t be. Most of my generation has grown up playing Japanese video games and watching Japanese cartoons. So whether they realise it or not they have been consumers of Asian media from a young age.

And for kids now it should be even easier. Whether it be a K-Pop song on YouTube or an Anime series on Crunchyroll, I think the advent of digital content distribution will do a lot to allow people to actively find international content to consume. And Hopefully this brings an end to this ‘foreign’ stigma that surrounds Asian media.